Dutch Schultz's Lost Fortune
Catskill Mountains, New York, USA · Buried ~1935
A gangster buried millions before he was gunned down.
The story
Dutch Schultz — born Arthur Flegenheimer — was one of the richest and most violent bootleggers of Prohibition-era New York, a beer baron and numbers racketeer who made and killed for fortunes. By the mid-1930s the law had found the angle that beat so many gangsters: not murder, but taxes.
Facing federal tax-evasion charges and the prospect of prison, Schultz reportedly decided to hide his liquid wealth where no prosecutor could reach it. The legend holds he had a special airtight, waterproof steel safe made, packed it with around $7 million in cash and negotiable bonds, and drove north with his trusted bodyguard Lulu Rosenkrantz to bury it in the Catskill Mountains of upstate New York.
He never came back for it. In October 1935 rival mobsters gunned Schultz down in a Newark chophouse. He lingered a day, feverish and rambling, while a police stenographer wrote down every disjointed word — a famous, dreamlike monologue that treasure hunters have combed ever since for a buried clue. If a location was in there, no one has read it out.
The bodyguard who supposedly helped bury it died in the same stretch of gang violence. So the only two men who knew the spot took it with them, and somewhere in the Catskills — if the story is true at all — a rusting safe full of Depression-era money may still be waiting under the leaves.
What’s known
- Dutch Schultz (Arthur Flegenheimer) was a major Prohibition-era New York bootlegger and racketeer.
- He was facing federal tax-evasion prosecution in the mid-1930s.
- He was shot in Newark, New Jersey, in October 1935 and died the next day.
- His delirious deathbed statement was transcribed by police and is part of the public record.
- No safe or buried cache attributed to Schultz has ever been found, despite decades of searching the Catskills.
What the legend holds
The legend holds that the safe is real and still out there, somewhere around the Phoenicia area of the Catskills, and that the key to it is hidden in Schultz’s deranged final words — read by some hunters as a literal coded map. Others think the money was never buried at all, or was quietly recovered by associates long ago.
What’s certain is the pull of it: a waterproof box of gangster cash under a mountain, its location locked inside a dying man’s hallucination. It is the most American kind of treasure — Prohibition money, mob violence, and a riddle nobody can solve.
Where it stands
STILL UNFOUND. Nearly ninety years on, no trace of Schultz’s safe has surfaced, and the Catskills keep the secret — if there was ever a secret to keep. It survives as a treasure hunt with a built-in cipher: the dying man’s own last words.
Hunt it for real
LootSkip hunts inspired by this legend — real, safe, in public places. Not the actual Dutch Schultz's Lost Fortune.
No hunts inspired by this legend yet.
The trail’s open, skippers. When someone posts a hunt themed on Dutch Schultz's Lost Fortune, it’ll appear here — real loot you can actually claim.
Theories
Here’s what the crew thinks — these are community theories, not LootSkip’s claim. Nobody knows where Dutch Schultz's Lost Fortune is. Make your case, fork a theory you’d build on, or challenge one you doubt.
No theories yet.
Be the first of the crew to make the case. Sign in, lay out your reasoning, and the hunt is on.
Some treasure stays legend. Yours doesn’t have to.
We’re charting dossiers like this one for every great unsolved cache. Meanwhile, real loot is already hidden near you — posted by skippers, free to hunt, won with a claim code inside the geofence.